Nicholas Kassotis found guilty of wife's murder and dismemberment
Nicholas James Kassotis was accused of murdering and dismembering his wife, Mindi Mebane Kassotis, in late 2022. Her dismembered remains were discovered in December 2022 in Liberty and McIntosh counties, Georgia. Following an investigation that identified the victim through forensic genetic genealogy, Kassotis was arrested in May 2023 in Pennsylvania and charged with multiple offenses including malice murder and felony murder. In August 2025, a jury found him guilty on all 12 counts, and he was sentenced to life without parole plus 25 years. He is currently serving his sentence.
Timeline
Want updates on this thread?
Track this storyTimeline of developments
August 2025 — 9 developments
Nicholas Kassotis dismembered wife, scattered remains across Georgia hunting preserve
New details reveal that Nicholas Kassotis dismembered his wife, Mindi, and scattered her remains across a Georgia hunting preserve. It was also reported that he had changed his name to Nicholas Stark.
Jury Foreman Kai Andrew Rejects Defense's 'Jim McIntyre' Argument as Lacking Evidence
During Nicholas Kassotis's sentencing, his mother stated the jury's verdict was incorrect. Additionally, the jury foreman, Kai Andrew, spoke out, noting that the defense's 'Jim McIntyre' argument lacked evidence and the jury found no proof of his existence.
Nicholas Kassotis to appeal conviction after wife testifies about fraud
During the trial, Nicholas Kassotis's third wife testified about his fraud and deception, and he was intensely cross-examined about his accounts. Following his conviction and sentencing, his defense attorney expressed disappointment and indicated Kassotis will appeal.
Judge Paul Rose Sentences Nicholas Kassotis to Life Without Parole Plus 25 Years
Immediately following the verdict, Superior Court Judge Paul Rose sentenced Nicholas Kassotis to life without parole plus an additional 25 years.
Liberty County jury finds Nicholas Kassotis guilty on all 12 counts, including malice murder
A Liberty County jury deliberated for approximately one hour before finding Nicholas Kassotis guilty on all 12 counts, including malice murder and felony murder.
Nicholas James Kassotis Testifies in Own Defense, Victim Statements Heard at Sentencing
Nicholas James Kassotis testified in his own defense and closing arguments were presented on August 13, 2025, during his trial. Victim impact statements were heard at his sentencing on August 15, 2025.
Defense presents 'CIA conspiracy' argument involving 'Jim McIntyre' in closing arguments
The state rested its case, and closing arguments were held, with the defense presenting a "CIA, conspiracy theory type argument" involving a fictional character named "Jim McIntyre" who allegedly controlled the couple's finances and movements.
Murder trial begins for former Navy JAG officer Nicholas Kassotis
The murder trial of former Navy JAG officer Nicholas Kassotis, facing 12 charges including malice murder and dismembering a body, began on August 8, 2025.
Nicholas Kassotis Murder Trial Begins in Georgia
The murder trial against Nicholas Kassotis began in Liberty County, Georgia, with prosecutors alleging he killed and dismembered his wife to avoid a $1.5 million divorce judgment from his first wife.
May 2023 — 3 developments
Nicholas Kassotis Charged with Malice Murder, Other Felonies; Awaits Extradition to Georgia
Nicholas Kassotis was charged with malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault, tampering with evidence, and removal of body parts from the scene of death or dismemberment. He was held awaiting extradition to Georgia.
Nicholas James Kassotis arrested in connection with Mindi Kassotis' death
Nicholas James Kassotis, Mindi's husband, was arrested in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, in connection with her death.
Remains of Mindi Mebane Kassotis identified through familial DNA comparison
The remains were positively identified as Mindi Mebane Kassotis, 40, through familial DNA comparison.
March 2023 — 1 developments
GBI and FBI used forensic genealogy and sketch to identify remains
Law enforcement, including the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI) and FBI, worked to identify the remains, utilizing advanced forensic genetic genealogy and a GBI forensic artist's composite sketch.
December 2022 — 2 developments
Dismembered remains, including legs and head, found in same area after initial discovery
In the days following the initial discovery, additional dismembered remains, including legs and a head, were found in the same area.
Hunters discover dismembered torso of woman in Georgia
Hunters discovered the dismembered torso of a woman on hunting club property spanning Liberty and McIntosh counties near Riceboro, Georgia.