Police Chief Resigns Amid Controversy Over Tel Aviv Football Ban Protests
West Midlands Police Chief Constable Craig Guildford resigned amid controversy surrounding the force's decision to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv football fans from a Europa League match in November 2025. The ban, initially justified by safety concerns, came under scrutiny after reports revealed flawed intelligence, including the use of AI to cite a non-existent match. The Home Secretary publicly expressed a loss of confidence in Guildford, leading to his resignation, and the matter has since been referred for an independent investigation.
Timeline
Want updates on this thread?
Track this story2026
14 updates
2026
14 updatesActing Chief Constable Scott Green referred several senior officers for investigation regarding the Maccabi Tel Aviv fan ban. The West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner, Simon Foster, stated he lacked the legal authority to dismiss the chief constable.
Scott Green has been appointed as the new acting chief of West Midlands Police, focusing on repairing damage to the Jewish community, following Craig Guildford's resignation after admitting to using incorrect evidence.
An accountability hearing is currently underway at the West Midlands Police headquarters to investigate the decision to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv fans. The hearing will examine the police's actions before, during, and after the ban was announced.
UK ministers are set to gain direct powers to dismiss failing chief constables as part of new police reform laws, a development linked to the fallout from the Tel Aviv fan ban.
A preliminary report by a British policing watchdog, which led to the police chief's resignation, is criticized for failing to include voices from Birmingham's Muslim community in its investigation of the fan ban.
Leaked audio from October 2025 reveals a senior West Midlands police officer claimed Birmingham residents planned to 'arm themselves' in self-defense before a Maccabi Tel Aviv match.
via jewishnews.co.uk
Chief Constable Craig Guildford of West Midlands Police announces his immediate retirement, stating that the 'political and media frenzy' surrounding his position had become detrimental to the force.
via getmoresports.com·jpost.com·thecanary.co·youtube.com·timesofisrael.com
Police issued clarifications regarding the Jewish community's involvement in the decision to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv fans, following controversy over the intelligence and justification used.
Sir Andy Cooke criticized senior police for fabricating evidence to justify banning Maccabi Tel Aviv fans, citing inaccurate information.
West Midlands Police Chief Craig Guildford apologized to MPs, admitting that incorrect evidence leading to the fan ban was generated by Microsoft Copilot AI, contradicting his initial claim that human research was responsible.
Official inspection reports from GOV.UK and His Majesty's Chief Inspector of Constabulary confirmed that West Midlands Police advised reducing ticket allocation to zero for the Maccabi Tel Aviv match and indicated errors in their handling of the fan ban.
via dailymail.co.uk·ministryofinjustice.co.uk·gov.uk·whispering.media
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood publicly announces she has lost confidence in Chief Constable Craig Guildford, following an independent report that highlighted 'a failure of leadership' and 'damning' errors in WMP's intelligence gathering for the ban.
via getmoresports.com·jpost.com·thecanary.co·youtube.com·timesofisrael.com
Police chiefs publicly defended their decision to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv fans to Members of Parliament, asserting it was based on safety concerns and intelligence suggesting local community members might arm themselves, while denying any conspiracy.
via youtube.com
Documents revealed West Midlands Police knew of antisemitism warnings weeks before claiming Jewish community support for the Tel Aviv football ban. This led to MPs demanding Chief Craig Guildford's resignation on January 15, 2026, and Commissioner Simon Foster announcing his retirement the next day.
2025
2 updates
2025
2 updatesReports emerge in UK media indicating that Dutch police dispute some of the evidence cited by West Midlands Police to justify the ban, raising initial questions about the intelligence used.
via getmoresports.com·jpost.com·thecanary.co·youtube.com·timesofisrael.com
The Europa League match between Aston Villa and Maccabi Tel Aviv proceeds in Birmingham without away fans, while protests related to the ban occur outside the stadium.
via getmoresports.com·jpost.com·thecanary.co·youtube.com·timesofisrael.com
2024
1 update
2024
1 updateTel Aviv Police Chief Ami Eshed has resigned, citing political interference from government members who allegedly demanded excessive force against protesters. Eshed stated he could not comply with these demands without violating regulations. This resignation is in protest against perceived government meddling in police operations.
2025
Story began · 5 months ago